clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Introducing Gladstone Street's Shut Up & Eat Pizza

To help celebrate Pizza Week, Eater paired up chefs with neighborhood pizzerias to collaborate on special, one-week-only pizzas. Next up: Gladstone Street Pizza welcomes Shut Up & Eat's John Fimmano.

[Avila, 3/17/14]

At his East Coast-style sandwich shop Shut Up & Eat, co-owner/chef John Fimmano offers a roast-pork sandwich "that's pretty traditional from where I grew up," he says. "The sandwich itself comes hot; it's kind of like a pork French dip, with an au jus. It's a wet sandwich." For a Pizza Week collaboration, Fimmano grabbed the pork-sandwich ingredients from his shop's new deli case and headed across the street to nine-year-old neighborhood pizzeria Gladstone Street Pizza, where co-owner/pizzaiolo John Mitchell re-creates the sandwich, subbing bread and provolone for pizza dough and mozarella. The result tastes close to the original sandwich: "Just in a different shape," Fimmano says.

The dough: Mitchell uses a traditional Neapolitan-style dough — just flour, water, salt, and yeast — creating what he calls "teeny little batches" in an old German bread machine (sometimes, Mitchell and his team will make six or seven 13-pound batches in one night). The result is a "soft and stretchy" dough, which Mitchell prefers to cook in a hotter oven: Set to 700 degrees, the Gladstone oven cooks a large pizza in four minutes.

The pizza: For the special Eater pizza, the duo use Mitchell's usual California-tomato sauce and a cheese blend of mozzarella and fresh-grated Pecorino-Romano, subbing them from the provolone and sharp asiago combination that would normally accompany the pork sandwich. Then, Fimmano adds the Shut Up toppings: To create the pork, Fimmano roasts a Carlton Farms pork butt to a medium-rare temperature, chilling the roast overnight before thin-slicing the meat, cold-cut style. The pork hits the pizza alongside blanched rapini (sauteed with garlic, olive oil, and chili) and house-roasted red peppers, which retain a char and sweetness normally not found in a picked version like Mama Lil's. The result is a savory slice of pizza with a dual crunch: from Mitchell's crust and Fimmano's rapini.

The details: The Shut Up & Eat pizza will be available at Gladstone Street Pizza all through Pizza Week: Score a 14-inch pie for $19 or an 18-inch pizza for $26. Gladstone's hours of operation: 5p.m. to midnight, daily.
· Gladstone Pizza [Official site]
· Shut Up & Eat [Official site]
· All Pizza Week 2014 Coverage [Eater PDX]

Shut Up And Eat PDX

3848 SE Gladstone Street, Portland, OR 97202

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater Portland newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world